Odein Princewill: The Complexities of Citizenship and Belonging in South Africa

The recent discussions surrounding the citizenship of a Miss South Africa 2024 contender reflect on the issue of persistent xenophobic behavior in the country, which is likened to internalized colonialism. The examination of South Africa’s history of racial segregation sheds light on the current xenophobic tendencies in the nation. Despite growing up in South Africa and having deep connections to the country, individuals of foreign heritage face challenges in being recognized as South African citizens.

The ongoing debate revolves around the eligibility of the Miss South Africa 2024 contestant, who, despite being born and raised in South Africa, is not considered a citizen due to her Nigerian and Mozambican roots. This situation highlights the xenophobic and Afrophobic sentiments present in South Africa, particularly in cases where individuals are not perceived as “fully” South African due to their heritage.

Similar instances have occurred in the past, such as a former Miss South Africa contestant facing backlash for her mixed heritage. These incidents raise questions about the criteria for being considered a South African citizen and reveal underlying biases and discriminatory practices within the country’s citizenship policies.

Reflecting on personal experiences and observations, it becomes evident that despite embracing diversity, South Africa struggles with inclusive citizenship policies that accommodate individuals with diverse backgrounds. The need for reevaluation and restructuring of citizenship concepts in a globalized world is emphasized, especially within the African context where discussions on migration, belonging, and inclusivity are crucial.

 

 

***

Feature Image by Asiama Junior for Pexels